Skip to main content

Forest Win Top of the Table Clash

After the violent trauma of Upton Park, it was good to return to the relative safety of Nottingham for a home game the week after  - and what a match to look forward to!: A top of the league clash against Forest's closest rivals, Manchester City, a team just one point behind with a slightly inferior goal difference.

A 116 season-long joint history

Manchester City and Nottingham Forest both joined the football league the same season, 1892-93, when the league was expanded from one division to two. The season before, Forest had won the Football Alliance, a league set up by Harry Radford who ran Forest in their early years to rival the football league. It had started three years earlier, just one season after the Football League - it was time for the two nascent leagues to merge.

As a consequence the number of teams in the league doubled from 14 to 28. The first division (the only one before the expansion) went from 14 to 16 teams, and a new Second Division was formed with a further 12.

As Alliance champions, Forest went straight into the First Division along with runners up Newton Heath (renamed Manchester United 9 years later) and The Wednesday (Sheffield Wednesday), whereas all but three of the other Alliance teams, including Ardwick (to be renamed Manchester City two years later) made up the new division two along with relegated Northwich Victoria.

The Last Alliance League 1891-92

In their first season in the league, Forest managed to survive in the top flight, whereas Manchester City faired reasonable well in the second division.

1892-93 Season - All teams named their modern way here
Forest remained top dogs for a few more years, but as with most of the teams we would face in the top flight that season, it wasn't long before the other lot became dominant over us.

In the 75 years of league history before this match, Forest had finished above City only 19 times, and 12 of those were in the years up to 1910. Forest's most dominant season over City was in 1964-65 when we finished 5th and they ended up 28 places below us, 11th in Division Two. City had bettered that differential 13 times, most emphatically in 1936-37 when City won the league for their first time and Forest ended up 39 places below them in 17th place in Division Two.


Forest and City had met 60 times before in competitive games and, not surprisingly, Forest's record didn't look too good.


Still, at least I had that cherished memory of the most fantastic match the last time we played Man City at home - that brilliant 4-1 win in the F.A. Cup 4th Round in front of over 42,000 when a fantastic Duncan McKenzie solo display destroyed City.

Although Man City had won the league twice, the F.A. Cup 4 times, the League Cup twice and the European Cup Winners Cup once, they had never dominated the league for more than a season. The closest they came to doing that was the three seasons between 1903-04 and 1905-06 when they had the same points as Newcastle but couldn't achieve top spot only on goal average. They were second best for the four seasons between 1974 and the season being reported on here, though. So, Forest were up against one of the best teams in England on 15th October 1977.

Manchester City's League "Glory Years"

Here are some of their greatest teams...

F.A. Cup winners 1903-04 (beat Bolton Wanderers 1-0 at Crystal Palace in front of 61,374)

F.A. Cup Winners 1933-34 (beat Portsmouth 2-1 at Wembley in front of 93,258)
This match was also notable as it was refereed by Stanley Rous, later to become Sir Stanley, the 6th president of FIFA.

League Champions 1936-37

F.A. Cup winners 1956 (Notice Don Revie?)
In the 1955-56 final Manchester City beat Birmingham City 3-1 at Wembley in front of 100,000 fans.

League Champions 1967-68 - How did they keep the trophy for this photo withe FA Cup which they won the year after?
Manchester City v Gornik Zabrze (Poland) 

Cup Winners Cup Winners 1970
Man City won their only European silverware at the Prater Stadium, in Vienna when they beat the Polish cup winners, Gornik Zabrze 2-1 in front of less than 8,000 fans.

League Cup Winners at Wembley 1970 (beat West Bromwich Albion 2-1 at Wembley)

...and again in 1976 when they beat Newcastle United 2-1, again at Wembley
So, as Man City came to the City Ground for the second time in four years, they were a top club. They had only missed out on the league title the season before on goal difference and had been top of the league for most of the weeks so far in this.

Manchester City Stars

They had a team of stars with eleven internationals in the squad including Joe Corrigan, Willie Donachie, Mike Doyle, Asa Hartford, Peter Barnes, Mike Channon, Brian Kidd and Dennis Tueart.

Asa Hartford

Brian Kidd

Joe Corrigan

Mick Channon on the day

Peter Barnes

Wille Donnachie

Teams

Nottingham Forest
1 Peter Shilton, 2 Viv Anderson, 3 Colin Barrett, 4 Mike McGiven, 5 Larry Lloyd, 6 Kenny Burns, 7 Martin O'Neill, 8 Ian Bowyer, 9 Peter Withe, 10 Tony Woodcock, 11 John Robertson.
Goals: Peter Withe 1, Tony Woodcock 1.

Substitutions: Archie Gemill (12) came on for Martin O'Neill(7).

Manchester City
1 Joe Corrigan, 2 Paul Power, 3 Willie Donnachie, 4 Gary Owen, 5 Mike Doyle, 6 Tommy Booth, 7 Peter Barnes, 8 Mike Channon, 9 Brian Kidd, 10 Asa Hartford, 11 Dennis Tueart.
Goals : Brian Kidd 1.

Substitutions: Kenny Clemments(12) came on for Dennis Tueart (11).

Attendance : 35,572

The Game

I watched this pulsating top of the table clash from the Trent End among Forest's biggest home crowd of the season so far. Brian Kidd gave Man City the lead in the 21st minute. After a couple of near misses at both ends, Man City contrived to give the ball away and John Robertson picked it up and darted into the box, and as he did, supplied the perfect cross to make it easy for Tony Woodcock to tap in the equaliser right in front of us before half time.

The second half was end-to-end stuff and anyone could have won it to be honest. But in the end it was Peter Withe that struck a scrappy goal to grab the points and allow Forest to maintain their lead at the top.


Other Matches that Day

Even though Forest beat their nearest challengers, they were immediately replaced in that role by Liverpool, who won to stay just a point behind the "tricky trees". Everton moved into 3rd place with another win.




Peter Withe's goal increased his lead at the head of the First Division's top scorer's chart.


Next up for Forest - another trip to London to face QPR.

The Match Day Programme



















Post No 15

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Stan Bowles fills the Brian Clough Stand

40 years ago, the Brian Clough Stand was nearing completion and, despite not yet having a roof, people started sitting in the vast array of seats of its upper tier. It wasn't called "The Brian Clough Stand" then, of course. Someone, bizarrely, thought "The Executive Stand" was appropriate. It would seem a perverse name, even in today's billionaire infused world of football, never mind in those dark days at the end of the 1970s, as Britain was only just throwing off its last flirtation with socialism. Filling the seats was something we had never really questioned, as Clough and Taylor had brought so much success to Nottingham in the last two years. The City Ground had attracted several 40,000+ attendances during this era, so getting 32,000 or so once the City Ground capacity was reduced,  would surely be no problem. However, Forest's league form seemed to suddenly become very fragile as the construction of the stand neared its completion. Most alarmingl

Cup dreams of Bury, buried by Forest

The 1977-78 season was sliding inexorably to the so-called "pointy-end" (meaning, I think, when things are decided). Forest, top of the first division by four points, after drawing 0-0 at Derby now turned their attention to a League Cup Quarter Final - the first time they'd ever got this far in the tournament. In their way stood third division Bury, who were looking for some cup glory themselves. They had already beaten 4th Division Crewe Alexandra, 3rd Division Oxford United, 2nd Division Millwall, and 1st Division West Bromwich Albion on their way to this quarter final. But, unlike Forest, they'd been here before. In fact if they won, Bury would get to the semi-finals of the League Cup for their second time. Could they do it, or would it be Forest's year? You know the answer but before describing my trip to the match let's pay respect to the long history of Bury F.C. and some of their great historical highlights. The North West is Football Mad

Forest Go Breaking Watford, Herts.

40 Years is a long long time. Here, touching back, brings us round again to find when Forest took a big step towards returning to returning to Wembley to defend the League Cup that they had won the season before (when they were victorious  over the mighty, mighty Liverpool in a replay at Old Trafford) by eliminating a swarm of ascendant hornets. (That's Watford, to those not acquainted with their nickname.) In this post, I'll give a brief outline of Watford Football Club's bizarre chameleon-like (but, it has to be said, remarkably unsuccessful) history before doing a big catch up with what had happened in the world of football in the weeks between Forest beating Brighton in the quarter finals back at the start of December, and this game. The most famous Watford fan, of course, is Reg Dwight. Y'know... Elton John - so I'll do a bit on him as well, interweaving his career into my life via my dear sister who, as far as I was aware, discovered him, and some of his f